return to first page linux journal archive
keywordscontents

At the Forge

CGI Programming

A quick guide to how CGI works and why it's a nightmare to debug.

by Reuven M. Lerner

How often has this happened to you: You finish a wonderful CGI program, place it on your server, fire it up, and...much to your chagrin, you find your browser telling you that there has been a ``server error'', rather than the expected output from the program?

There is no shame in having this sort of thing happen; experienced CGI programmers see this message plenty of times each week. And while experience might reduce the number of errors a programmer makes, more often it teaches him or her how to deal with such problems.

This month, we will look at all the things that need to be in place so that a web server can run your program. These problems tend to cause programmers an awful lot of trouble, in part because they change the programming paradigm we are used to from our other programming experience.

We Don't Run Things Directly

Most programs are run directly, invoked from the command line (or a graphical user interface), and then displayed on your screen. But CGI programs are different; they are almost always run on a different computer from the one at which the user is sitting. Worse, CGI programs are twice-removed from the user--the user tells the browser what he or she wants to do; then the browser has to pass that data to the server, which then passes the request (and any arguments) along to the program. Thus part of the secret of debugging CGI programs simply involves understanding that the server is invoking the program.

Just like all of the other programs on your system, CGI programs must be executable. This isn't a big deal to remember when you are coding in C and C++, since gcc and other compilers produce an executable file that has the correct execution bits turned on. But for those of us who write most of our programs in Perl (and similar languages, such as Tcl and Python, which make use of the Unix shell's interpreter), we need to make sure that the programs are executable before they will run. This might sound obvious, but believe me--from the e-mail I get, I can assure you that many people writing and installing CGI programs forget to make sure that their program is readable and executable not only to themselves, but also by the user ID under which the web server is running.

So, if you are getting an error message when running your CGI program, go to the directory in which it is located, and use the Unix ``chmod'' command to make it executable. Since you want to make it executable to all users on the system--a good idea, given that web servers often run under the ``nobody'' ID--we can issue the following command:

chmod a+x progname
Thus if my program is called ``progname'', we can double-check to make sure that the program is executable by issuing the ls command with the -l option, indicating that it should provide information in the ``long listing format''. This means that we should like to see information about the file's permissions, ownership, and modification dates, as well as its name. If we list our program, we should see something like:

-rwxrwxrwx 1 reuven reuven 12779 Sep 5 15:28 progname
The above means that ``progname'' is owned by the user named ``reuven'' and the group named ``reuven'' (not unusual on my personal Linux box!), that it was last modified on September 5th at 3:28 p.m., and that it is 12779 bytes long. But most important is the fact that we see the string ``rwx'' repeated three times--first for the user (``reuven'' in this case), then for the user's group (again, ``reuven'' in this case), and then for everyone else on the system. Thus the three instances of ``rwx'' mean that anyone on the system can read, write, and execute progname, which is precisely how we want things to be.

Running from the Command Line

If the program is executable and still gives you problems, your next step should be to run the program from the command line. As I said earlier, we always have to remember that the web server (most likely a different machine than ours) is executing the program on our behalf, which means that we usually see not the program's output, but rather the results of what our browser does with that output! It's generally easiest to debug when we know exactly what the program is doing, and thus it can only help to execute the program on the web server itself.

So if the program is called ``progname'', change into its directory (using the cd command) and type:

	./progname
Why precede the program's name with the ./? Because your shell's PATH variable usually won't--and probably shouldn't--include your system's CGI directory, which means that were you to simply type the program's name, your PATH might not work. Unless you already include ., a.k.a the current directory, in your PATH, which is extremely convenient but also a potential security risk. Suffice it to say that the above recipe always works, while leaving off the ./ won't always do the trick.

When you execute the program, what do you see? Most important of all is that a MIME header be the first thing the program sends to its output. Browsers depend on MIME headers to know what sort of data the program will be sending its way, and without such a header, you will almost always get an error from your browser. Why? Because if the browser expects to receive a MIME header, but instead receives an HTML-formatted response from your program, it will usually not know what to do. Rather than display data incorrectly, your browser simply says (in its own terse way) that it didn't understand what sort of data it should expect. It's up to you to make sure that under all circumstances, anything sent to standard output is preceded by a MIME header.

While there isn't enough space to go into the intricacies of MIME headers this month, suffice it to say that unless your program is going to output something other than HTML, you should always make sure that the first thing it prints is:

Content-type: text/html
Also note that this string should be followed by two newline characters (\n in C and Perl), rather than the one that we are used to placing after text strings. That is, Perl programmers should write:

print "Content-type: text/html\n\n";
while those of you (wisely) using the CGI.pm module in Perl should be able to do the following:

use CGI;         # Bring in the CGI module
my $query = new CGI; # Create an instance of CGI
print $query->header("text/html"); # Output the header
Why two newline characters? Simply put, those two newlines separate your program's headers (i.e., information about the response) from the content that it returns (i.e., the response itself). There is at least one major precedent for this system that you probably use all of the time--e-mail! If you ever look at an e-mail message as transmitted via SMTP (the Internet's Simple Mail Transfer Protocol), you will see that the message's headers and contents are separated by a blank line.

What else should you look for when running your program from the command line? If your program is invoked using the GET method (i.e., if it is invoked as though it were a document, without any arguments beyond perhaps some on the command line), then invoking it from the command line should produce some output, even if the output will be a bit weird because of the lack of any input arguments. However, if your program looks at the environment variable QUERY_STRING as a source of input, then you can easilyset that value from the Unix shell. If you're using bash or some similar sh/ksh variant on your system, then you should be able to type:

export QUERY_STRING="hello+there"
  ./program-name
Note that while you don't have to write characters in QUERY_STRING in the Web's ``percent-hex'' encoding scheme (in which odd characters are replaced by a percent sign, followed by the hexadecimal number representing their ASCII code), I suggest that you do, if only to test your program in an environment as close as possible to the one in which it will be invoked. Remember that if we want to know why things are going wrong, we need to pretend to be the web server invoking the program--otherwise we might miss out on a subtle bug that has to do with the encoding (or lack thereof).

Testing out programs that use POST is a bit trickier, since the name/value pairs are difficult to emulate when you are invoking the software on your own. But luckily for those of us using Perl, the CGI.pm module allows us to run our programs from the command line without too much trouble. If you invoke a program that uses CGI.pm, you'll see:

  ./program-name
(offline mode: enter name=value pairs on standard
input)
At this point, you can enter all of the names and values of the elements in the HTML form that is supposed to invoke the CGI program, followed by control-D. Of course, you don't necessarily have to enter all of the form elements, particularly if you're testing a large form--after all, debugging is supposed to save you time! But it is certainly convenient to be able to type:

name=Reuven
email=reuven@NetVision.net.il
address=17+Disraeli+Street
equation=2%2B2%3D4
<control-D>
and see the results of my program with that input, rather than having to add lots of print statements to my program--a tried-and-true system, and one which I certainly use, but this is often much easier. Note that in the above examples, my address has been entered with plus signs between the words (since the space character cannot be transmitted as part of a URL), and with the plus sign (+) and equals sign (=) encoded in percent-hex format.

Since I'm already talking about Perl a bit, let me remind all of you Perl programmers to use the -w flag when running your programs! The warnings it produces can be invaluable, especially when coupled with the ``diagnostics'' package that describes problems in more detail. You should also seriously weigh using the ``strict'' package, which forces you to declare variables a bit more formally than many Perl programmers are used to doing--but the trade-off is that the Perl compiler is then able to identify potential problems as it is looking at the program. Thus most of my CGI programs have the following in their first few lines:

/usr/local/bin/perl5 -w

use strict;         # Interpret variable and
	            # subroutine names strictly
use diagnostics;    # Display documentation
	            # regarding each warning
		    # and error.
use CGI;	    # Bring in the CGI module

Was the Directory Configured for CGI?

By this point, we know that the program is executable, that it sends the correct MIME header before any other output, and that it seems to work in at least a basic way if invoked from the command line.

So assuming that there aren't any logic errors--which are still a significant hurdle to overcome, even when all of these logistical errors are out of the way--we should make sure that the program is running in a directory that has been configured to run CGI programs!

First, let's think about how most programs work: When you request a document from a server, it generally makes sure that the file exists. If the file does exist, the server returns the document to the browser; if it doesn't, the server returns an error message indicating that the file wasn't found.

CGI programs work slightly differently, though--in this case, the server returns any output returned by the program, rather than the program itself. Thus the server attempts to execute the file as if it were a program, and then takes whatever that program returns and passes it on to the user.

Now the question: How does the server know which files it should simply return, and which should be executed first?

On most systems, that distinction is made by assigning several directories to be for CGI programs. These directories, traditionally called ``cgi-bin'', contain the binaries (i.e., the executables) for our CGI programs. Anything contained in these directories is considered to be a program, and is executed; anything sitting elsewhere is considered to be a text file. Thus if your program is sitting in a non-CGI directory, its contents will be sent to the user as if they were a text file, displaying approximately what you would see if you were to use the Unix more command. By the same token, if you were to put one of your HTML documents in the CGI directory, requesting it would almost certainly cause an error, since the server would attempt to execute it!

Another approach, which is less common, allows users to place CGI programs anywhere on the system, so long as their filenames have certain suffixes--for example, .cgi or .pl. The good news is that this allows users to have their own CGI programs without forcing the system administrator to configure a new CGI directory each time a user wants to have a counter, or other common CGI program, on his or her home page. However, CGI programs can be a security risk, particularly when any user on the system can write or install whatever programs he or she might want. Most system administrators prefer being bothered with requests to create new CGI directories to the potential security holes that might exist with the other approach.

In either of these cases--the cgi-bin directory approach or the ``any directory'' approach--users who experience problems with their CGI programs should make sure that their programs are in the right directories, that the CGI directories are set up for CGI programs, and that they have the right suffixes. I often get e-mail from people who wonder why they get the error cannot perform POST method to the non-script whenever they try to execute their CGI program. What this admittedly terse and cryptic error message is trying to say is, ``You tried to send data from an HTML form to a file that doesn't appear to be a program. If you want to set this up as a program, make sure to define it as such on your system by using the appropriate configuration!''

The solution, then, is to make sure that your program is in one of the directories declared to be for CGI programs. Your system administrator should be able to do this by using the ScriptAlias directive (for NCSA httpd and Apache), or the Exec directive (for CERN httpd). Once that is done, your program should run--although once again, I should stress that just because all of the above steps are in order doesn't mean that your program will work! It just means that your server will be able to run it, and that the program will return at least some results to your browser.

Next Time

That's all the space we have for this installment. Next month, we will discuss the httpd error log, to which our programs send all of their error messages and warnings when things go wrong. We will see how to read the error log, and how to understand what it is saying when our programs don't work when we expect them to--as well as how to use it to our advantage to make sure that our programs work correctly.

Reuven M. Lerner has been playing with the Web since early 1993, when it seemed like more of a fun toy than the world's Next Great Medium. He currently works from his apartment in Haifa, Israel as an independent Internet and Web consultant. When not working on the Web or informally volunteering with school-age children, he enjoys reading (on just about any subject, but especially computers, politics, and philosophy-- separately and together), cooking, solving crossword puzzles, and hiking. You can reach him at reuven@the-tech.mit.edu or reuven@netvision.net.il.

  Previous    Next